Publications

Authors:

Velo Dalbrenta, D.; Cominelli, L.; Bombelli, G.

Title:

Revealing criminal motives: Legal cognition between science, rhetoric and criminology

Year:

2026

Type of item:

Articolo in Rivista

Tipologia ANVUR:

Articolo su rivista

Language:

Inglese

Format:

Elettronico

Referee:

Sì

Name of journal:

OÑATI SOCIO-LEGAL SERIES

ISSN of journal:

2079-5971

N° Volume:

Vol. 16 (2026)

Number or Folder:

No. 2

Page numbers:

663-679

Keyword:

Criminal motives; criminal responsibility; intention; criminal science; forensic rhetoric; criminology

Short description of contents:

If crime is the most reprehensible betrayal of social bonds and expectations, and therefore deserves the most severe legal sanction (punishment), the assessment of criminal responsibility must be exceptionally accurate. At trial, jurists must evaluate not only the rational dimension of conduct, as expressed through the defendant’s (presumed) intention; they are also required to address and, as far as possible, to reveal the defendant’s underlying motives, no matter how “irrational” these may appear, since they arise from emotions, feelings, passions, and moods. In doing so, jurists should be aware that such motives are grasped through the interplay between the conceptualisations provided by criminal law, as elaborated and systematised by legal doctrine in the form of criminal science, and the set of arguments discovered, developed and discussed by forensic rhetoric on the basis of common sense, as filtered and organised through a criminological approach grounded in criminal types. Yet, as far as concerns us here, these “irrational” motives — complementary to the rational intention first addressed at trial — make particularly clear how the application of criminal law in the end relies on otherwise implicit forms of social knowledge, precisely as conveyed by criminal science, forensic rhetoric, and criminology.

Product ID:

150982

Handle IRIS:

11562/1190308

Last Modified:

April 27, 2026

Bibliographic citation:

Velo Dalbrenta, D.; Cominelli, L.; Bombelli, G., Revealing criminal motives: Legal cognition between science, rhetoric and criminology «OÑATI SOCIO-LEGAL SERIES» , vol. Vol. 16 (2026) , n. No. 2 , 2026 , pp. 663-679

Consulta la scheda completa presente nel repository istituzionale della Ricerca di Ateneo